KLG is open 8.30am-5.30pm, 5 days a week and fully operational during the COVID-19 quarantine. We are available to serve our clients , as well as serving potential new clients.

Employment Law & HR News & Updates.

Employment Law Updates

The latest employment law news & updates from Kalra Legal Group
3 minutes reading time (508 words)

Unlawful Deduction of Wages - Contractual Disputes: Agarwal v Cardiff University and another

shutterstock 215808085

A worker who suffers a deduction from wages may bring a claim in the employment tribunal to recover the shortfall if it was not made in accordance with a written agreement with the employer or provided for in writing within the contract of employment itself. In Agarwal v Cardiff University and another, the EAT held that a claim for unlawful deduction of wages cannot be made where the employment tribunal would have to engage in an exercise of interpreting the terms of the contract in order to decide whether or not there has been a deduction.

Ms Agarwal l was employed by Cardiff University as a senior lecturer in urology and – as is common with such posts – also had what is known as an ‘honorary contract’ with the local health board under which she undertook a range of clinical duties. She was therefore regarded as having two employers – although she was paid solely by the University. A separate arrangement between the University and the health board, meant that they shared the cost of her salary between them.

In 2014 Ms Agarwal was absent for an extended period of time because of a stress-related illness arising from various difficulties she had experienced in her relationships with colleagues. When she was certified as fit to return to work, the University accepted her return but the health board felt that she could not safely return to clinical duties until some of those difficulties had been resolved and they asked her to participate in mediation. She refused to do so until some of the issues that she had raised had been investigated, but in the meantime asserted that she was ready willing and able to undertake the full range of her medical duties.

The health board persisted in its belief that she should not be allowed to undertake clinical work, however, and withheld funds from the University. As a result, she only received half of her salary. She took both employers to an employment tribunal alleging that she had suffered an unlawful deduction from her wages.

The employment tribunal held that it had no jurisdiction to hear her complaint and the EAT agreed. To determine whether there had been an unlawful deduction, the tribunal would have been obliged to carry out a detailed interpretative exercise to decide whether her entitlement to payment for clinical work depended on her actually performing such work or at least cooperating with the employer in any assessment of her fitness or attempts to resolve the issues regarding her relationships with colleagues. The unlawful deduction from wages regime was not intended to be a forum for resolving disputes as to the interpretation of a contract and the tribunal had no jurisdiction to undertake that exercise. The issue would have to be resolved in a claim before the civil courts.

Contact Us Today

If you have any concerns regarding the above issue, or wish to speak to one of our specialist employment lawyers, please call us on 0808 1151 040 or complete our online enquiry form.

Zero Hours' Contract - Exclusivity Clauses
Employers Urged to Tackle Discrimination

Call us 0800 8321554

Make an enquiry

Contact Kalra Legal Group

Please let us know your name.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your email address.
Please write a subject for your message.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your message.

What our clients say

“I am extremely grateful for the support I received from Anita during a very difficult time with a previous employer. It felt I was in a battle, but someone else was fighting that battle for me. Anita had my best interest at heart all the way, I really cannot praise her enough.”

R.B – Director at Software company

“I cannot thank you enough for all your efforts over the last 6 months working with our company to ensure we have taken all the necessary steps to protect our business and treat all our female staff equally.”

A.B - Managing Director of a Software Company

Contact us

Head Office
Suite 4, Ground Floor
Braywick House West, Windsor Road,
SL6 1DN 

4th Floor
86-90 Paul Street

Tel: 08008321554
Email: info@klglaw.co.uk

This website uses cookies to improve functionality and performance. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.